南韓中學生眼裡的世界 (?) - 韓國

By Damian
at 2010-06-10T00:42
at 2010-06-10T00:42
Table of Contents
今天幫學生上課的空檔,順手拿起書櫃上的"社會教科書"來看。
南韓雖沒有諸如國立編譯館的統一版本,但我看的那幾家(大概3家),內容都差不多=.=
依靠極粗略印象,中一教世界歷史,中二世界地理,中三為較深入的韓國社會國情等。
吸引我注意的有幾點~
1. 世界歷史包含不少中國近代史,但感覺重點focus在中國屈辱的近代史,及日本對亞
洲國家的侵略行為(有提香港割讓給英國,但沒提到台灣割讓給日本)。
例如有講到洋務運動、太平天國等等,文化類的內容則較少。
還有,中國歷史人物的名稱及地名簡直是亂七八糟;韓國近年的取向是用"音譯",但我
的感覺是譯得不三不四,又不統一(韓國小孩應該背得很X杯)。
例如"李鴻章"跟"洪秀全"是用韓文發音(對韓國孩子應是最易記憶的方式)、"康有為"是
用現代普通話的音譯,用諺文表示則有4個字(他要是地下有知應該會很囧,因為康有為
可是著名普通話講不標準的啊XD)、"孫文"的名字最奇怪,竟然拼成 Ssun Won...不是
韓文也不是廣東音也不像北京音也不是西方慣用稱法...誰可以告訴我WHY???
2. 世界地理把台灣歸為東亞(那為什麼還是很多韓國人把台灣當成東南亞國家?),部分
教科書把台灣和中國標成不一樣的顏色XD
在東亞這章只提中國和日本(韓國本身是另外開好幾章),此外加了一句香港是亞洲金融
中心,97年回歸中國。
該篇則隻字未提台灣,"台灣"僅在地圖上有標出來而已,所以韓國中學生不知道台灣應
該是很可以理解的。
3. 自欺欺人的歷史?
當然韓國教科書會提到南北韓分裂,但地圖上則統一標成"大韓民國"。
在我看來,這跟當年台灣國立編譯館教科書自欺欺人的行為沒有兩樣。
不論ROC vs PRC 或 ROK vs DPRK,不管政府政策方針是怎樣,兩國分立本來就是事實,
這個事情難道不應該讓學生知道嗎? 講他們太年輕不會懂,這我不同意。
不會懂是因為沒有教! 而不是年紀小!
韓國十幾歲的小女生都可以穿著暴露大跳艷舞,懂個南北韓分立這個事實難道那麼難嗎?
只是國立編譯館1999年就仆街了(...我承認我是用那個超lag國中教科書的最後一屆XD),
韓國現在,難道還在欺瞞中學生嗎...???
(高中教科書怎麼寫我就不知道了,有了解的可以分析一下?)
--
南韓雖沒有諸如國立編譯館的統一版本,但我看的那幾家(大概3家),內容都差不多=.=
依靠極粗略印象,中一教世界歷史,中二世界地理,中三為較深入的韓國社會國情等。
吸引我注意的有幾點~
1. 世界歷史包含不少中國近代史,但感覺重點focus在中國屈辱的近代史,及日本對亞
洲國家的侵略行為(有提香港割讓給英國,但沒提到台灣割讓給日本)。
例如有講到洋務運動、太平天國等等,文化類的內容則較少。
還有,中國歷史人物的名稱及地名簡直是亂七八糟;韓國近年的取向是用"音譯",但我
的感覺是譯得不三不四,又不統一(韓國小孩應該背得很X杯)。
例如"李鴻章"跟"洪秀全"是用韓文發音(對韓國孩子應是最易記憶的方式)、"康有為"是
用現代普通話的音譯,用諺文表示則有4個字(他要是地下有知應該會很囧,因為康有為
可是著名普通話講不標準的啊XD)、"孫文"的名字最奇怪,竟然拼成 Ssun Won...不是
韓文也不是廣東音也不像北京音也不是西方慣用稱法...誰可以告訴我WHY???
2. 世界地理把台灣歸為東亞(那為什麼還是很多韓國人把台灣當成東南亞國家?),部分
教科書把台灣和中國標成不一樣的顏色XD
在東亞這章只提中國和日本(韓國本身是另外開好幾章),此外加了一句香港是亞洲金融
中心,97年回歸中國。
該篇則隻字未提台灣,"台灣"僅在地圖上有標出來而已,所以韓國中學生不知道台灣應
該是很可以理解的。
3. 自欺欺人的歷史?
當然韓國教科書會提到南北韓分裂,但地圖上則統一標成"大韓民國"。
在我看來,這跟當年台灣國立編譯館教科書自欺欺人的行為沒有兩樣。
不論ROC vs PRC 或 ROK vs DPRK,不管政府政策方針是怎樣,兩國分立本來就是事實,
這個事情難道不應該讓學生知道嗎? 講他們太年輕不會懂,這我不同意。
不會懂是因為沒有教! 而不是年紀小!
韓國十幾歲的小女生都可以穿著暴露大跳艷舞,懂個南北韓分立這個事實難道那麼難嗎?
只是國立編譯館1999年就仆街了(...我承認我是用那個超lag國中教科書的最後一屆XD),
韓國現在,難道還在欺瞞中學生嗎...???
(高中教科書怎麼寫我就不知道了,有了解的可以分析一下?)
--
Tags:
韓國
All Comments

By Suhail Hany
at 2010-06-10T09:14
at 2010-06-10T09:14

By Cara
at 2010-06-13T19:11
at 2010-06-13T19:11

By Rachel
at 2010-06-14T13:28
at 2010-06-14T13:28

By Hazel
at 2010-06-14T18:56
at 2010-06-14T18:56

By Barb Cronin
at 2010-06-19T02:54
at 2010-06-19T02:54

By Callum
at 2010-06-24T01:14
at 2010-06-24T01:14

By Hamiltion
at 2010-06-24T08:22
at 2010-06-24T08:22

By William
at 2010-06-29T00:17
at 2010-06-29T00:17

By Damian
at 2010-06-30T09:29
at 2010-06-30T09:29

By Ophelia
at 2010-07-03T04:34
at 2010-07-03T04:34

By Victoria
at 2010-07-07T18:09
at 2010-07-07T18:09

By Kristin
at 2010-07-09T23:12
at 2010-07-09T23:12

By Andy
at 2010-07-13T06:29
at 2010-07-13T06:29

By Iris
at 2010-07-14T14:33
at 2010-07-14T14:33

By Edward Lewis
at 2010-07-15T06:37
at 2010-07-15T06:37

By Mary
at 2010-07-19T04:16
at 2010-07-19T04:16

By Leila
at 2010-07-20T08:58
at 2010-07-20T08:58

By Victoria
at 2010-07-20T16:10
at 2010-07-20T16:10

By Linda
at 2010-07-25T15:20
at 2010-07-25T15:20

By Kama
at 2010-07-29T08:50
at 2010-07-29T08:50

By Ida
at 2010-08-01T17:47
at 2010-08-01T17:47

By Catherine
at 2010-08-02T04:18
at 2010-08-02T04:18

By Annie
at 2010-08-02T16:34
at 2010-08-02T16:34

By Catherine
at 2010-08-06T15:59
at 2010-08-06T15:59

By Tom
at 2010-08-10T13:49
at 2010-08-10T13:49

By Freda
at 2010-08-11T01:54
at 2010-08-11T01:54

By James
at 2010-08-11T20:13
at 2010-08-11T20:13

By Zanna
at 2010-08-13T21:46
at 2010-08-13T21:46

By David
at 2010-08-16T07:33
at 2010-08-16T07:33

By Joseph
at 2010-08-17T12:14
at 2010-08-17T12:14

By Anthony
at 2010-08-19T09:02
at 2010-08-19T09:02

By Dorothy
at 2010-08-20T21:27
at 2010-08-20T21:27

By Heather
at 2010-08-23T21:18
at 2010-08-23T21:18

By Blanche
at 2010-08-27T20:01
at 2010-08-27T20:01

By Una
at 2010-08-28T04:48
at 2010-08-28T04:48

By Agnes
at 2010-08-29T13:18
at 2010-08-29T13:18

By Hardy
at 2010-08-30T10:46
at 2010-08-30T10:46

By Hardy
at 2010-09-04T06:17
at 2010-09-04T06:17

By Charlotte
at 2010-09-07T08:01
at 2010-09-07T08:01

By Rae
at 2010-09-11T08:48
at 2010-09-11T08:48

By Isla
at 2010-09-13T11:14
at 2010-09-13T11:14

By Gilbert
at 2010-09-14T05:14
at 2010-09-14T05:14

By Tom
at 2010-09-17T02:27
at 2010-09-17T02:27

By Bennie
at 2010-09-20T20:50
at 2010-09-20T20:50

By Eartha
at 2010-09-25T05:55
at 2010-09-25T05:55

By Linda
at 2010-09-27T05:31
at 2010-09-27T05:31

By Poppy
at 2010-09-28T23:08
at 2010-09-28T23:08

By Agatha
at 2010-10-03T10:38
at 2010-10-03T10:38

By Emily
at 2010-10-05T01:44
at 2010-10-05T01:44

By Christine
at 2010-10-07T07:44
at 2010-10-07T07:44

By Hedwig
at 2010-10-07T20:27
at 2010-10-07T20:27

By John
at 2010-10-12T03:36
at 2010-10-12T03:36

By Hamiltion
at 2010-10-15T00:06
at 2010-10-15T00:06

By Genevieve
at 2010-10-19T20:25
at 2010-10-19T20:25

By Carolina Franco
at 2010-10-24T01:44
at 2010-10-24T01:44

By Una
at 2010-10-27T16:03
at 2010-10-27T16:03

By Lauren
at 2010-10-30T04:47
at 2010-10-30T04:47

By Robert
at 2010-11-01T19:41
at 2010-11-01T19:41

By Vanessa
at 2010-11-02T00:16
at 2010-11-02T00:16

By Lauren
at 2010-11-03T05:33
at 2010-11-03T05:33

By Sandy
at 2010-11-07T12:01
at 2010-11-07T12:01

By Lydia
at 2010-11-08T12:14
at 2010-11-08T12:14

By Kelly
at 2010-11-11T23:05
at 2010-11-11T23:05

By Ina
at 2010-11-12T07:49
at 2010-11-12T07:49

By Edith
at 2010-11-13T10:13
at 2010-11-13T10:13

By Lydia
at 2010-11-17T18:25
at 2010-11-17T18:25

By Enid
at 2010-11-19T12:05
at 2010-11-19T12:05

By Lauren
at 2010-11-20T22:53
at 2010-11-20T22:53

By Franklin
at 2010-11-24T22:17
at 2010-11-24T22:17

By Gary
at 2010-11-28T19:54
at 2010-11-28T19:54

By Cara
at 2010-12-01T10:16
at 2010-12-01T10:16

By Sierra Rose
at 2010-12-01T21:34
at 2010-12-01T21:34

By Olive
at 2010-12-03T05:13
at 2010-12-03T05:13

By Doris
at 2010-12-06T02:49
at 2010-12-06T02:49

By Daniel
at 2010-12-09T07:19
at 2010-12-09T07:19

By Yedda
at 2010-12-13T12:21
at 2010-12-13T12:21

By Queena
at 2010-12-17T14:29
at 2010-12-17T14:29

By Heather
at 2010-12-19T09:58
at 2010-12-19T09:58

By Joe
at 2010-12-21T02:19
at 2010-12-21T02:19

By Annie
at 2010-12-23T11:41
at 2010-12-23T11:41

By Annie
at 2010-12-28T01:22
at 2010-12-28T01:22

By Rachel
at 2011-01-01T10:08
at 2011-01-01T10:08

By Kama
at 2011-01-01T15:44
at 2011-01-01T15:44

By Anthony
at 2011-01-04T03:31
at 2011-01-04T03:31

By Daph Bay
at 2011-01-07T04:09
at 2011-01-07T04:09

By Blanche
at 2011-01-10T12:09
at 2011-01-10T12:09

By Kumar
at 2011-01-15T09:12
at 2011-01-15T09:12

By Oscar
at 2011-01-15T22:27
at 2011-01-15T22:27

By Ula
at 2011-01-20T14:16
at 2011-01-20T14:16

By Frederic
at 2011-01-25T02:44
at 2011-01-25T02:44

By Daph Bay
at 2011-01-27T02:13
at 2011-01-27T02:13

By Frederic
at 2011-01-31T13:58
at 2011-01-31T13:58

By Hazel
at 2011-02-05T04:18
at 2011-02-05T04:18

By Barb Cronin
at 2011-02-06T11:59
at 2011-02-06T11:59

By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2011-02-10T22:00
at 2011-02-10T22:00

By Sandy
at 2011-02-13T08:54
at 2011-02-13T08:54

By Necoo
at 2011-02-18T03:48
at 2011-02-18T03:48

By David
at 2011-02-18T22:00
at 2011-02-18T22:00

By Anonymous
at 2011-02-23T20:14
at 2011-02-23T20:14

By Joe
at 2011-02-24T10:57
at 2011-02-24T10:57

By William
at 2011-02-28T21:26
at 2011-02-28T21:26

By Rosalind
at 2011-03-04T19:39
at 2011-03-04T19:39

By Zenobia
at 2011-03-06T04:14
at 2011-03-06T04:14

By Todd Johnson
at 2011-03-08T10:06
at 2011-03-08T10:06

By Poppy
at 2011-03-10T04:33
at 2011-03-10T04:33

By Ophelia
at 2011-03-14T18:25
at 2011-03-14T18:25

By Jake
at 2011-03-16T15:37
at 2011-03-16T15:37

By Jack
at 2011-03-19T17:55
at 2011-03-19T17:55

By William
at 2011-03-20T05:24
at 2011-03-20T05:24

By Hardy
at 2011-03-21T01:58
at 2011-03-21T01:58

By Rosalind
at 2011-03-23T15:35
at 2011-03-23T15:35

By Hardy
at 2011-03-28T08:29
at 2011-03-28T08:29

By Puput
at 2011-03-31T05:21
at 2011-03-31T05:21

By Hazel
at 2011-04-04T20:04
at 2011-04-04T20:04
Related Posts
請問韓國當地或知道這牌保養品的朋友

By Olivia
at 2010-06-09T23:51
at 2010-06-09T23:51
在韓國韓幣換美金的地方(已爬文)

By Eden
at 2010-06-09T23:06
at 2010-06-09T23:06
上海世博會:南韓館舉行鄭律成音樂會

By Joe
at 2010-06-09T21:42
at 2010-06-09T21:42
請問去韓國推薦買什麼

By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2010-06-09T20:42
at 2010-06-09T20:42
金正日三子接班啟動?北韓高層大地震

By Catherine
at 2010-06-09T18:44
at 2010-06-09T18:44